Marty, Rory's Perfect Mate?

Is Marty Rory's perfect mate? Hmmm...not really, but he is better than Logan. Wait, make that so much better than Logan. Marty is this really sweet, autumn, non-rich, non-full-of-himself, non-jerk who really cares about Rory and not just for sex. In his last GG installment (S5's Jews and Chinese Food), his heart was gutted when Rory disclosed her emotional state for Logan. And even though Marty and fans knew she liked Logan (it did take a map to get that idea), it was a heart-breaking moment. We watched Marty pine for the young Gilmore for awhile, and we knew where the story was headed, but he was the ultimate underdog. And for that reason (plus his compatibility with Rory) no one could have sided against him. No one...unless you dream of your mate as an over-privileged white boy. Anyhoo. It appears that that is Rory's type, for Doctor Laura only knows why.

But is Marty that different from Rory's other seasonal guys? He's a drinker; we saw that from day one. And as GG has progressed, Rory's guys (Dean, Jess, Logan) have all dab into the liquor bottle at some point or another for some reason or another. Marty also possesses Dean and Jess's destitute. That's a second Rory-type trait. Yes, Logan doesn't fit in to that category (obviously), but you can count that really as Rory chasing something new. Plus, Marty is smart. That he has in common with Rory as well as Jess and Logan. Dean was a little on the slow side. But as you can see, Marty does seem to drum to the beat of Rory's mating call. So what do you think? Is Marty Rory's perfect mate? Can you think of any other traits that fit to the Rory-type? Do you detest Marty? If so, why?